According to the legend, the unique Berik Sea Amphitheater appeared after a landslide in 2005. He claimed that the structure was built in 393 AD, called it one of the oldest amphitheaters in the world, and told visitors incredible stories. According to him, Julius Caesar had been here, returning from Egypt with Cleopatra, and in the nearby church, Juliet Capulet supposedly lived. The story was so convincing that the site was even included in a tourist guide to Vicenza, published with the support of the European Union. The truth was revealed only in 2016, when carabinieri brought in archaeologists and cultural heritage protection specialists for an inspection. The examination showed that the 'ancient ruins' were made of fiberglass, papier-mâché, plaster, and modern gypsum elements. Moreover, satellite images confirmed that first, Malosso leveled part of the hill, and then built a decorative structure in its place. Historians also easily debunked the legends fabricated by the tour guide. Julius Caesar lived about four centuries before the date of construction that the fraudster claimed, and the action of the tragedy 'Romeo and Juliet' does not take place in Vicenza, but in Verona. The court found Malosso guilty of illegal construction, forgery of an architectural object, and unauthorized erection of structures. He was sentenced to two years and four months in prison, ordered to pay a fine of three thousand euros, and to demolish the fake amphitheater, restoring the original appearance of the hill. Additionally, the municipality is seeking to recover another 560,000 euros from him as compensation for damages. ...This story shows that even the most incredible legend can seem true for a long time if presented beautifully. However, modern technologies, expert evaluations, and the diligent work of historians ultimately set everything straight, turning a long-standing tourist sensation into a high-profile fraud case.