Foto: BB.LV / судебный молоток

After several years of legal proceedings, the mother of the 11-month-old girl who died at the Daugavpils Regional Hospital has achieved a final decision on compensation. The state is to pay her €123,792 from the Medical Risk Fund. The court found that the child's death was related to the improper actions of the medical staff. According to the LETA agency, the Supreme Court refused to initiate cassation proceedings on the complaint of the Ministry of Health. Thus, the decision of the appellate court has entered into legal force. ### **Why the Supreme Court rejected the ministry's complaint** The Ministry of Health attempted to challenge the ruling that entitled the mother of the deceased child to compensation. However, the Supreme Court established that the ministry's complaint essentially boiled down to disagreement with how the courts of previous instances assessed the evidence. The ministry insisted on a different interpretation of the circumstances of the case but did not provide sufficient grounds for revising the decision in cassation. The Supreme Court reminded that the cassation instance checks the correctness of the application of legal norms, rather than re-examining the factual circumstances. The court also found no grounds to believe that the girl's death was caused solely by her existing health problems or the actions of her mother. The causal link established by the lower court between the unprofessional actions of medical staff and the child's death was deemed justified. ### **How the tragedy occurred** The tragedy occurred in 2022. The mother noticed that her 11-month-old daughter might have swallowed valerian tablets and immediately called for an ambulance. The girl was taken to the Daugavpils Regional Hospital and placed in the intensive care unit. After a while, the medical staff deemed her condition relatively stable and decided to transfer the patient to another department. Before transporting the child, she was disconnected from the monitor that was tracking her heartbeat and breathing. However, the requirements for medical supervision stipulated continuous monitoring of vital signs during transportation. The journey to the department on the fifth floor took about 20 minutes. During this time, a physician's assistant and a nurse were by the girl's side. However, there was no equipment that could timely alert about a cardiac arrest. The medical staff believed the child was sleeping. When the girl was delivered to the children's department, the on-duty medical staff discovered that she was not breathing. It was determined that death occurred during transportation or just before its completion. ### **Health Inspection initially found no fault with the doctors** After the girl's death, the Health Inspection conducted an investigation and concluded that the actions of the medical staff were correct. The agency considered the version of sudden infant death syndrome. According to the inspection, the possible poisoning by valerian was not severe enough to cause the child's death on its own, and the sudden deterioration of her condition was allegedly unforeseeable. The mother disagreed with these findings and went to court. During the trial, a comprehensive forensic medical examination was appointed, involving five specialists, including experts in intensive care, pediatric infectious diseases, and pathological anatomy. ### **Experts rejected the sudden infant death syndrome version** The forensic medical examination revealed significant shortcomings in the assistance provided to the girl. The specialists rejected the explanation of death as sudden infant death syndrome, establishing that the immediate causes were acute heart failure and asystole — the cessation of electrical activity of the heart. According to the experts, the critical deterioration of the child's condition began earlier than the medical staff noticed. If the girl had remained connected to the monitor, the medical staff could have timely detected changes in her heart activity and taken necessary actions. The court established that by transporting the child without proper supervision, the staff missed the moment when there was still a chance to save her life. ### **Inconsistencies found in medical documents** Particular attention during the proceedings was drawn to the records in the medical documentation. In particular, the child's chart indicated blood pressure readings at 11 a.m. However, the court established that at that time, the girl was already being transported or prepared for transfer, and she was not connected to the medical monitor. This raised doubts about the reliability of the corresponding records. The court concluded that the data could have been entered retroactively or did not reflect the measurements actually taken. At the same time, the court did not establish that the doctors intentionally harmed the child. The issue was one of inadequate medical supervision and untimely provision of necessary assistance. ### **Compensation must be paid within a month** Back in December 2025, the Administrative District Court in Rezekne recognized the decisions of the Health Inspection and the Ministry of Health to deny compensation as unlawful. On April 22, 2026, the Administrative Regional Court upheld the conclusions of the first instance. The court established that the medical staff did not ensure the necessary monitoring of the child's condition and did not take timely actions to preserve her vital functions. The Ministry of Health attempted to appeal this decision; however, the Supreme Court has now refused to initiate cassation proceedings. According to the court decision that has entered into force, the Health Inspection must, within a month, arrange for the payment of compensation to the mother from the Medical Risk Fund. The amount of compensation is €123,792.30. Thus, a long-standing legal dispute has concluded, in which the mother had to prove in court that her daughter's death was related to deficiencies in medical care.